We use cookies to give you the best experience possible. By continuing we’ll assume you’re on board with our cookie policy

A critical reaction to Edward Said’s essay Essay Sample

essay
  • Pages: 5
  • Word count: 1,231
  • Rewriting Possibility: 99% (excellent)
  • Category: philosophy

Get Full Essay

Get access to this section to get all help you need with your essay and educational issues.

Get Access

Introduction of TOPIC

Said has propelled the post-colonial/Orientalism approach to literary criticism into interesting places for the modern reader. Complicating the political approach and critical meanings that we the (non-other) reader takes from the novel about colonial history. Language is the active issue of reading and representation (that all readers must engage with) when forming opinion on the text. The postcolonial political approach is, of course, easy to summarise. As understanding and approaches to the countries that do not happen to be members of the privileged ‘west’ and their peoples have changed. So too has our approach to ‘our’ history, the view to ‘their’ history. Colonial and cultural Imperialism being a well-recognised mistake of the western world’s history, through revaluation of the human cost it has made on its victims.

As well as the now ‘dubious’ approach to the justifications the enlightened world made of itself. For example… John Lock’s belief that the right to own land belonged to those who would ‘work’ it rather than those who are ‘on’ it was used as justification for the seizure of the ‘new worlds’ and out posts. The postcolonial critic now views political events and histories from other perspectives different to our own. In Culture and Imperialism Said writes: “What we need to do is to look at these matters as a network of independent histories” (Rice and Waugh. 348). Politicising the central issues of the text, studying the ‘language’ and justifications that it gives us, or the political situations that the character find themselves in.

Relative and ‘other’ histories and the disclosure, of their politically ‘marginalized’ position, now being the objective, the modus operandi of post colonial discourse. To understand the ‘other’ within our psyche and without, and to reinterpret a one politely ‘one-sided’ world view. To form a new outside perspective that can view history [histories] from not only the overview that western philosophy aspires, but to also view from the ‘other’ perspective. Said writes in his essay about the 1900 text; Lord Jim on the ‘presentation of narrative’: “In all cases the dominating factor is not narrative energy but a fatalistic desire to behold the self passively as an object told about, mused on, puzzled over, marvelled as fully, in utterance.

That is, having everywhere conceded that one can neither completely realize one’s own not fully grasp someone else’s life experience.” (LJ. 456) none of us can be fully realised enough to see a situation from all perspectives, or fully understand the colonial mind of our past, or the ‘victims’ alienated mind, we are effectively beyond the reach of communication by such motivating agents and forces. This was realised by Conrad as he presents many of the problems of narrative and communication and r

ecognised by Said in his essay as he identifies key hesitations, problems in the text that is within

Sorry, but full essay samples are available only for registered users

Choose a Membership Plan
the text. As the book is not only the story that Conrad tells us (a trusted author) who recounts the tale that the character tells… a somewhat less reputable narrator. Perhaps, we form judgements on his story on account of weather he is or ‘is not’ one of “us”.

‘He is one of us’ the text keeps telling us, but we are forced to question the meaning of this phrase, the difficulties that the characters have in communicating their knowledge and experiences to each other. “Each sentence drives a sharper wedge between intention (wanting-to-speak) and communication. Finally wanting-to-speak, a specifically verbal intention, is forced to confront the insufficiency, and indeed the absence of words for that intention.” (LJ. 456) Just as the difficulties that cultures have in communicating, (the chasms between words and word meanings) it as if we must not only take the unsettling truth of Wittgenstein (when he will not categorically deny the existence of a rhinoceros in this room at this time) and then multiply it to the power of different language and cultures. “He is one of us.”

The assurance factor in the language game, the participation in a(my) cultural context that sees us of the same ilk (we both can agree on the name of the thing that is called a rhinoceros and such a thing is not in this room at this time, and so on for more nebulous concepts other than simple animal names). Said recognises that Conrad, in Lord Jim, explores the events that can pull a character out of their cultural context, into new and unsettling situations that make an ‘alien’ of them.

This character that finds himself in the traumatic situation of a sinking ship, or washed ashore amongst people with a different language. The generation gap between himself and those that the character gives his testimonial to and the judgement that they bring from the perspective of imperialist domination that further alienates Jim. The patchy dialogue between Marlow and Jim is an incomplete testimonial that is never quite fulfilling, neither for Marlow or for us, if we are not sympathetic to or at least trying to understand the ‘other’ perspective. Marlow, like us, does try to understand this ‘patchy’ and in-sustainable ‘oral report’ but garners it only much later.

The narrative, as postcolonial criticism never lets us forget, belongs to the victor and it is this narrative that we must now question. Can we ever step out of ourselves and view the (not our) past, as Said suggests; as ‘independent histories’? This statement is not the problem, we can believe that there is such a thing as more than one moral position as we view an instance in history, but the exercise of removing moral judgement or holding many moral views is near impossible1.

History is made up of morally and culturally guided events, even if morality is misguided or we detect lapses; we are forming a judgement from a moral position. Leaving the only course of action most beyond moral indignation is the avoidance of judgement and action all together. To simply judge is to take a moral position, but post-colonial criticism takes a different path. With its intentions close to that of the postmodernist theories it seeks to deconstruct and problematize our assurances (moral and cultural).

The doubt and trepidation with which we might now approach the ‘Victors narrative’ affects Marlow’s understanding of the imperial world when he further reflects on Jims account. By shifting perspectives, or moral views, we might move to a position not of assurance but of doubt, and therefore inaction (a pleasant place for some of the professional political thinkers of the world, but not for the ‘doers’). Post colonialism shows many of its connections to the strategies post-structuralism and postmodernism, in this respect, as ‘meaning’, ‘symbolic-structure’, and other such assurances tumble in on themselves we are find that we are in the ‘multi-centred’ world that post-colonialism aspires to, and binds us to; morally neutral inaction that is vindicated by a redeeming measure of sympathy for all.

Reading

Conrad, Joseph. Lord Jim. Norton Critical Edition. 1996 2nd Edition.

Rice, Philip, and Waugh, Patricia. (editors) Modern Literary Theory, A Reader. Arnold Books. 1996 3rd Edition.

We can write a custom essay on

A critical reaction to Edward Said’s essay E ...
According to Your Specific Requirements.

Order an essay

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

A Philosophical View - Do Animals Have...

Should animals be harmed to benefit mankind? This pressing question has been around for at least the past two centuries. During the early nineteenth century, animal experiments emerged as an important method of science and, in fact, marked the birth of experimental physiology and neuroscience as we currently know it. There were, however, guidelines that existed even back then which restricted the conditions of experimentation. These early rules protected the animals, in the sense that all procedures performed were done so with as little pain as possible and solely to investigate new truths. Adopting the animals' perspectives, they would probably not agree that these types of regulations were much protection, considering the unwanted pain that they felt first followed by what would ultimately be their death. But, this is exactly the ethical issue at hand. For the most part, animal rights are debated in regards to two issues: 1) whether...

A Comparison of Classic and Contemporary Philosophers

Why is it so important that young children in our society receive a good education? The answer to that question is very simple; because they are our future. The old saying "the youth of today are the leaders off tomorrow" holds more truth than many people realize. By giving children a good start at an early age we are only helping ourselves as well as the children. A good example of this is can be seen in our society. By the time a teacher in our society retires from his or her position their students will have made it out into the real world and taken jobs. This new generation will be the ones to make the decisions about laws such as Social Security, and Medicaid. The students will be able to turn these programs around and make them more beneficial to their recipients. These teachers who are now retired...

The 5 Branches of Philosophy

Healthcare is considered one of the backbones of our society and is integrated into every aspect of our lives. When talking about different areas healthcare, we can use philosophy to better understand the basic principles involved in healthcare. Philosophy can be divided into five different branches; metaphysics, epistemology, ethics, politics, and esthetics. These five branches show the different perspectives of healthcare to better understand how the related to one another. Philosophy and healthcare can be related using the example of female circumcision. While female circumcision is a practice and ritual that is very common in many societies, it is viewed on the opposite spectrum here in the United States. The use of philosophy allows an individual to see female circumcision for what it is and from a more unbiased position. Metaphysics is the study of existence, and asks the question, "What is out there? " There are probably many people...

Popular Essays

logo

Emma Taylor

online

Hi there!
Would you like to get such a paper?
How about getting a customized one?