We use cookies to give you the best experience possible. By continuing we’ll assume you’re on board with our cookie policy

Black Elk Speaks and Autobiography Essay Sample


Get Full Essay

Get access to this section to get all help you need with your essay and educational issues.

Get Access

Introduction of TOPIC

Over the 10 weeks I have been learning about what an autobiography is and other things as well. (In my opinion, an autobiography entails someone’s life story from the time they can remember up until present day, and is written and edited by that person). During this course I was assigned to read several passages, and I was trying to determine whether or not they were autobiographies. One passage that comes to mind is by author V. S. Pritchett, Writing an Autobiography. After reading this I had a better understanding of what an autobiography should entail. The last passage that I read caught me by surprise because I really had to concentrate on key phrases, or sentences that helped me understand that it was an autobiography. John Neihardt, the author of, Black Elk Speaks, could be interpreted as something else rather than an autobiography, because Black Elk didn’t write it. Black Elk told the story to his son Ben Black Elk. Who then translated It in English to John Neihardt, and his daughter to record.

After doing research on line about the book Black Elk Speaks, I noticed that there was a lot of controversy about the author of the book. Which entailed whether or not the book actually was written word for word that came out of Ben Blacks mouth? The primary argument made is that Neihardt, being the author and the editor, was able to exaggerate or change so

me parts of the story. He did so to make the story more palatable and marketable to a white audience

in the 1930s. When I was reading through this book I found myself questioning numerous times, whether or not this truly was an autobiography or if it was something else. (I say this because throughout the book there are other tribe members that

I know that an autobiography is one’s life story written by the author, and is narrated by them as well. I now know that there can be exceptions to that rule because of the circumstances of language barriers, or being illiterate, I also understand why there was so much controversy with John Neihardt and his book, Black Elk Speaks. (Maybe he knew that if he were to change facts he would sell more books and it would help his finances.

The pure autobiographer is concerned with shaping a past from the standpoint of a present that may be totally unlike it. That is why you tore up those 20 pages and paused to consider who your first-person singular is and what “truth” you intend to state. For there is no absolute truth. You will be unable to tell all or you will be incapable of it. Or let us hope that you are, for one definition of a bore is that he is a man who tells you everything. (“V. S. Pritchett. Writing an Autobiography 381”).

This goes without saying that an autobiography should be convincing and believable. Over time you tend to forget the past, especially you adolescent years. When you are writing an autobiography keep it within reason, and not just make up something to fill in blank. Your difficulties with truth-telling arise from the fossilization of memory. The longer one lives, the less certain one is of who one is. “(382).”

I was under the impression that the term autobiography has the same definition across the board, but I have come to realize that there are other definitions. I believe that a lot of the time a memoir is easily mistaken for an autobiography. A memoir is written by whomever it is about, but only covers one chapter in his or her life.

Works Cited

V. S. Pritchett: “Writing an Autobiography,” reprinted from Page 2, ed. Francis Brown. (New York: Holt, Rhinehart & Winston, Inc., 1969). Copyright by V.S. Pritchett. Reprinted by permission of Harold Matson Co., Inc.

HTTP:// en.Wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Elk_Speaks

Sorry, but full essay samples are available only for registered users

Choose a Membership Plan

We can write a custom essay on

Black Elk Speaks and Autobiography Essay Sample ...

According to Your Specific Requirements.

Order an essay

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

Maya Angelou - I Know Why The...

In Maya Angelou autobiography 'I know why the caged bird sings' many themes and issues are looked at. This autobiography shows the difficulty of a black woman growing up surrounded by discrimination and poverty, but also shows her determination, joy and hope. Maya Angelou describes her relationship with many character, this in it self is a theme of her writing, the way she sees people in her own light. Some characters that may be seen to be good people are changed by Maya's opinion. A good example of this is the contrast between Maya's mother and Maya's father's girlfriend. If both these characters were described, the father's girlfriend maybe considers the better person. This is not the case after reading this book, as Maya has a way of making the reader see these characters as she sees them. After the separation of Maya Angelou's parents she and her brother Bailey...

Eb White's: Why is The Lake a...

E. B. White’s “Once More to The Lake” is an autobiography essay in which White embarks on why the lake is a meaningful place to him. He states that every summer, he would visit this lake in Maine arriving on August first and staying for one month .White realize that bringing his son along with him made him comprehend that nothing has changed since he has been to the lake as a child and that seems to comfort him. He sees his son as him and he as his father. In the essay, White uses the words peace, goodness and jollity to describe why the lake is a meaningful place to him. First, white uses peace to describe why the lake is a meaningful place to him. The first evidence that he envisions the lake as a place of peace and holiness is when he metaphorically compares it to being...

Bertrand Russell’s “What I Have Lived For”

The prologue of his autobiography, Bertrand Russell’s “What I Have Lived For” lists the three chief purposes of the aging scholar’s existence – love, knowledge, and pity for human suffering.  None of his goals are purely carnal or self-interested, even love, which he characterizes as ecstatic and even heavenly, transcending ordinary existence. In his quest for knowledge, Russell has sought answers to higher questions of human existence and the human mind; like his search for love, it has a deep spiritual significance for him, and he shows no overt self-interest in either aim.  His sense of pity, however, grounds him in earthly reality, particularly in the realization that he is powerless to halt the world’s suffering; however, this sense of futility does not leave him embittered or frustrated.  On the whole, this brief piece attests to Russell’s higher emotional and intellectual aims, yet it also displays his sense of humility...

Popular Essays


Emma Taylor


Hi there!
Would you like to get such a paper?
How about getting a customized one?