We use cookies to give you the best experience possible. By continuing we’ll assume you’re on board with our cookie policy

Comparing Newspaper Texts Essay Sample

essay
The whole doc is available only for registered users OPEN DOC

Get Full Essay

Get access to this section to get all help you need with your essay and educational issues.

Get Access

Comparing Newspaper Texts Essay Sample

“Its wrong to give the under 12’s homework” is the strong statement used as a title in text A. It is used as a metaphor to tap into our morals and set us immediatly into the train of thought of the article. Text B, on the other hand has a title of no great imagery effects, it mearly tells us that “Blunkett sets targets for daily homework”, plain and simple, as if it was an obvious plus factor and needs no backing up.

Text A is a tabloid, and so would naturally contain converse anithesis to that of the broadsheet; text B. The first paragraphs are of the deepest contrast too, in terms of view and expression. The tabloid A states the idea of compulsory homework for under twelves is “condemned in a report by education experts out today.” Immediatly we pick up the word “experts” and reference is made to a professional opinion. Its goes on to try to convince us that “Homework is not always a good thing” by including it in the same sentence as “20 minutes study a night for five-year-olds”. Somehow it doesn’t stike us as being fair but actually quite wrong, although no hard evidence is stated at this point.

Text B starts with language used to convince us that homework is for the reason of “raising the standards in the three Rs” and calls it a crusade; ____ to a movement of some sort. The next few lines go on to illustrate how we should learn from the time spent “crmming” in independant schools, implying the system used in state schools is unsufficient.

This is not the only reference to independant schools, in fact there are at least 4 mentions of it. Some might think the writer was snobby, feeling those who buy their education have automatically got the best way of doing it. But in the whole article only 3 paragraphs are not quotes of Mr Blunkett so any blame can go directly to him. This offers the reader a wider freeedom of opinion as they can take what analasis they want of his words and choose whether or not they want to agree with his views.

The tabloid has no direct references to Mr Blunkett, but only a spokesman for him. It doesn’t have as many quote, and the ones that it does have are not the strongest of evidence. Dr Cowan staes that “Too much work can cause mental fatigue for youngsters” which again uses language to arrouse our sympathy for the children. (note the pet-word youngsters)

One arguement fron text A is that those from poorer homes don’t have the conditions to do homework. This is another announcement by Dr Cowen. The paper failed to mention the grant of �200 million for after school clubs used especially for the homework of poorer children in the country.

The only real fact in the article of text A was that in 1935 school inspectors urged a ban on homeworks for the reason that it made then too tired for lessons. This evidence does not strike out at us in any real way because of the illogic of it. All children have boundless mental energy, and 20 minutes at the age of five would certainly not tire the child out in any harmful way.

The British Phychological Socitiey give evidence that “teachers can find homework too time consuming” and can be “poorly thought out.” I do not know what they are trying to say here. It could be that the teachers are to blame, and that they need to think about planning homework and make it work for the children. Or they could be saying that the homework is not done properly by the children because they have not had enough time to get it explained for them.

The Incorporated Association of Prep Schools are said to have praised the governments intentions about homework according to text B but they said homework was more about “quality not quantity”.

The general secretary of the National Association of Schoolmasters said “homework is an important part of the learning process but how much and when should be a metter of professional judgement.” The journalist for this article put these particular quotes in to back up Mr Blunkett. He looks like he cas covered all the “buts” in the speeches and so looks like he has got it all sussed.

The last paragraph is put in to up his appearance even more, as he is refered to as “not a miserable man” but wanting children to enjoy homework for all the best reasons.

We can write a custom essay

According to Your Specific Requirements

Order an essay

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

An American abolitionist newspaper The Liberator

In 1830, The Liberator was established by William Lloyd Garrison, he was an abolitionist and a member of the American Colonization Society. On the discussion of slavery, majority of the members thought a solution for the slaves to move back to west Africa would be ideal. However, Garrison had advocated for the urgent end to slavery and to encourage rights and freedom for all slaves...

Report Based on Research Study on English...

I looked at a range of tabloids and broadsheets. I wanted to find out what, exactly, was really inside an English newspaper. To do this accurately, I needed a mathematical formula to work out percentages of different categories within the paper. This formula is: A x B x C D x 100 = Percentage Where: A = the size of the paper B = the...

The Front Pages of Two Daily National...

I have chosen two different newspapers one is 'THE TIMES' (it is a broadsheet) and the other is 'THE SUN' (this is a tabloid). Considering that both newspapers were printed on the same day I would expect them to be similar and cover the same news titles. The reason for the difference in style and content is because both newspapers must satisfy a particular audience....

Commentary on Newspaper Article

My first piece of original writing is a newspaper article which is intended for a broadsheet paper like The Times or The Guardian. For my article I decided to write about rape. This is a subject that I personally feel strongly about. Rape is considered a taboo subject as no one wants to speak out about, society would rather behave as if these incidents do...

Newspaper Comparison

The paper contains one of the main news stories on the front page, a section on all news, a section on the arts, a separate paper fpr the sports, financial matters, and stocks. This paper is a more serious paper, for older readers. Title of main story: "Heads ready to replace A levels with new exam" The article is about head teachers preparing to introduce...

Get Access To The Full Essay
icon
300+
Materials Daily
icon
100,000+ Subjects
2000+ Topics
icon
Free Plagiarism
Checker
icon
All Materials
are Cataloged Well

Sorry, but copying text is forbidden on this website. If you need this or any other sample, we can send it to you via email.

By clicking "SEND", you agree to our terms of service and privacy policy. We'll occasionally send you account related and promo emails.

Your Answer Is Very Helpful For Us
Thank You A Lot!

logo

Emma Taylor

online

Hi there!
Would you like to get such a paper?
How about getting a customized one?