We use cookies to give you the best experience possible. By continuing we’ll assume you’re on board with our cookie policy

Decision Making Model Analysis Essay Sample

The whole doc is available only for registered users OPEN DOC

Get Full Essay

Get access to this section to get all the help you need with your essay and educational goals.

Get Access

Decision Making Model Analysis Essay Sample

The definition of decision making according to Wikipedia is “the cognitive process of selecting a course of action from among multiple alternatives” (2006, ¶ 1). Every decision made creates a final choice. Decision making begins when one needs to accomplish something but is unsure how. Decision making can be a rational or irrational reasoning process (Wikipedia, 2006).

Many decision-making models have been developed. One of the models is the Vigilant decision making model. This model provides a framework for the Pathway Evaluation Program. The Pathway Evaluation Program uses this model as a tool to evaluate entering the medical and pharmaceutical fields. The Vigilant decision-making model is applicable to any career-option decision. The American Pharmacists Association claims this model to be “alert, thorough, open, and persistent in looking at and evaluating different possibilities” 2003, ¶ 1).

The first step of the Vigilant decision-making process is appraising the challenge. In this step, one should determine the importance of informed decision-making and acknowledge the consequences of making a passive decision. In making career decisions, a person needs to recognize the importance of taking an active role rather than assuming things will work out. Making a career decision is a difficult task that requires thought and time. Problems will occur if one underestimates the demands of the task or postpones the task (APha, 2003).

The second step is assessing oneself. A person should conduct a thorough self-analysis and assess goals, values, strengths, skills, interests, and preferences. To make a good career decision requires self-knowledge. Self-examination is a difficult task for many people. Making the correct career decision requires an analysis of personal traits (APha, 2003).

Step three is surveying alternatives. Many career paths are available, and one can rule out many options right away. This could be because one does not have the time, energy, or resources to review all possibilities, or one already has an idea what he or she wants to do. A person may overlook exciting possibilities in skipping this step (APha, 2003).

The fourth step is evaluating alternatives. In this step, a person has a list of alternatives and needs to evaluate them. The person searches for new information, matches the self-assessment with the career options, and considers both the positive and negative consequences of all alternatives. Matching preferences and priorities to options that are attractive is important. A person needs to remain open and objective when evaluating the alternatives. Sometimes in this step, steps 2 and 3 may need revisiting (APha, 2003).

The fifth and final step is achieving commitment. After reviewing all the factors, reaching a conclusion is the last step. People must decide the best course of action, which includes a contingency plan in case the first choice does not work out. One must be both intuitive and analytical in this process (APha, 2003).

Critical thinking is necessary in all of these steps. One needs to identify, analyze, and evaluate the options in each step. If in step one, appraising the challenge, students did not analyze the challenges and enrolled without critical thinking, they may fail or drop out once the challenges are realized. If students do not identify their strengths and weaknesses in step two, the wrong course of study may be chosen, and they may find out there is no interest in the classes. Students must identify and evaluate the alternatives using critical thinking to find all possible avenues available. Achieving the commitment is an accumulation of the critical thinking process used in the prior steps. Hopefully, if students used critical thinking strategies, the final step will be easy.

This model is very applicable in a job-related decision. I currently work at US Bank as a business analyst. Before this position, I was a unit manager over the lease accounting area. Management changes in July 2005 and the consolidation of the lease and loan accounting teams resulted in my current position. The accounting area is not an enjoyable area.

Three years ago, a decision was made to return to school. When making this decision, people have to go through the Vigilant decision-making process to decide what area of study appeals to them. Further advancement in my career was not possible without a degree. The commitment involved in returning to school and working full time was a challenge needing appraisal. The consequences of not returning to school would result in a dead-end job.

Then I conducted a self-analysis of my goals, values, strengths, skills, interests, and preferences. Close coworkers were asked for their opinions. In conducting this analysis, I found I liked to work with people in helping make their employment experiences enjoyable and rewarding.

The alternatives were surveyed. These alternatives were limited to a course of study that was available in the evening. At this time, I was only thinking of returning for an associate’s degree. This was probably an oversight in surveying the alternatives, as I never considered a bachelor’s degree. Luckily, the decision worked out in the end.

Since the alternatives were limited to evening programs for an associate’s degree at Fox Valley Technical College, the two alternatives were human resources and supervision. I was already in a supervisory role and believed the human resource program my best choice. The skill assessments led me to believe that the human resource program was the better alternative.

In achieving commitment, I enrolled in the human resources evening program at Fox Valley Technical College. This decision was not a disappointment. This was believed to be my best course of action, and therefore I did not consider a contingency plan.

In December 2005, I graduated from Fox Valley Technical College with an associate’s degree in applied science in human resources. In May 2005, I started realizing that an associate’s degree was still not going to advance me in my career. I was already in a well-paying job that normally would have required a bachelor’s degree. With this realization, the decision-making process began again.

The process repeated with appraising the challenge of continuing school, assessing myself, surveying the alternatives, evaluating the alternatives, and achieving the commitment. I started at University of Phoenix in August 2005 in the bachelor’s program for management with an emphasis on human resources. This required doubling up on classes and attending two different schools for a while, but this was an understandable challenge.

All these decisions apply to my workplace, as I desire to remain an employee at US Bank and needed to find a course of study that would allow me advancement and entitle me to tuition reimbursement. I am hoping to finish my continuing education in early 2007. At that time, I can explore the possibility of transferring to one of the many US Bank locations around the country. I still keep searching the company’s job intranet site for advancement at my current location in Oshkosh.

The Vigilant decision making model is a continuous process that started with the idea of returning to school for an associate’s degree, then was revisited to continue for a bachelor’s degree, and advancement opportunities at work. At this time, there are no plans for a master’s degree. Since at the time of obtaining an associate’s degree, the thought of continuing for a bachelor’s degree did not cross my mind for a long time, I now realize that possibility cannot be ruled out.

In comparing the Vigilant decision making model to the 9-step decision-making model, some steps are similar, and some are expanded further upon. The 9-step model starts with identifying the problem, which is similar to appraising the challenge. Assessing yourself could be compared to defining criteria, goals, and objectives, and evaluating and identifying problems. Frame alternatives and evaluate alternatives equal the same as the Vigilant’s model step 2 and 3 of surveying and evaluating alternatives. The Vigilant model’s step 4 of achieving commitment is the same as step 7 and 8 make or implement the decision. The 9-step model expands on the process by measuring impacts. The 9-step model more clearly identifies steps and is not as broad as the Vigilant’s model. The models are different because the Vigilant model is designed for determining a career, while the 9-step model is for framing the problem.

All decisions can benefit from the Vigilant decision making model and the 9-step decision-making steps model. Major decisions in life, such as marriage or divorce, could take the steps of appraising the challenge, assessing oneself, surveying alternatives, evaluating alternatives, and achieving the commitment. Knowing the path to take to achieve a decision ensures the decision is thoroughly researched.


American Pharmacists Association APha. (2003). Pathways program components. Retrieved April 25, 2006 from http://www.aphanet.org/Pathways/decisionmakingmodel.htm

Pathway Evaluation Program. (2001). Retrieved April 25, 2006 from http://pathway.gsk.ca/medicine/index.html

Wikipedia. (2006). Retrieved April 25, 2006 from http://en.wikipedia.org/

We can write a custom essay

According to Your Specific Requirements

Order an essay

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

Left and Right Side Brained

There is no reason for an argument on which side of the brain is better because they are both used for different functions. A good example would be that most people who are left sided are often more logical than the right. The right side is said to be more intuitive thoughtful and subjective. The right side of the brain theory grew out of the...

The Dramatic Point of View of "Hills...

This story, Hills Like White Elephants, is taken form the Objective (dramatic) point of view where the author is the narrator. The author doesn't enter the mind of the characters at any time. He allows us only to see the characters as we would in real life. This is sometimes called the dramatic point of view. The only way we, the reader, learn anything about...

Cognitive Resilience in Adulthood

ABSTRACT A resilience framework for understanding cognitive aging implies a search for factors that buffer against existing risk, enabling one to thrive in what might otherwise be adverse circumstances. The cascade of biological processes associated with senescence and a cultural context that does not take into account this biological imperative each create risk for cognitive decline in later adulthood. We propose that (a) engagement, a...

Cognitive Psychology

During this course, I have learned that Clinical Psychology uses both research and practice to be able to understand and assess the problems and illnesses of their patients. Their tasks includes the early prevention and intervention of secondary problems of disturbed individuals ranging from infants to older people, as well as promote mental health in individuals, families, groups and organizations. In the period of assessment,...

Communication and Cognition

Introduction             Research is diverse in nature and the aims are even more diverse. It would be interesting to note that getting the compliance of the participants and extracting information that would enhance the results is not an easy task. Appropriate parameters must be assessed and determined before embarking on the actual research technique. The cooperation of the patients needs to be solicited many a...

Get Access To The Full Essay
Materials Daily
100,000+ Subjects
2000+ Topics
Free Plagiarism
All Materials
are Cataloged Well

Sorry, but copying text is forbidden on this website. If you need this or any other sample, we can send it to you via email.

By clicking "SEND", you agree to our terms of service and privacy policy. We'll occasionally send you account related and promo emails.
Sorry, but only registered users have full access

How about getting this access

Become a member

Your Answer Is Very Helpful For Us
Thank You A Lot!


Emma Taylor


Hi there!
Would you like to get such a paper?
How about getting a customized one?

Can't find What you were Looking for?

Get access to our huge, continuously updated knowledge base

The next update will be in:
14 : 59 : 59
Become a Member