We use cookies to give you the best experience possible. By continuing we’ll assume you’re on board with our cookie policy

Descartes Vs Berkeley Perception Essay Sample

essay
  • Pages: 2
  • Word count: 517
  • Rewriting Possibility: 99% (excellent)
  • Category: mind

Get Full Essay

Get access to this section to get all help you need with your essay and educational issues.

Get Access

Introduction of TOPIC

Both Descartes and Berkeley had a thesis of mediate perception. These theses however, were not the same. The difference, you see, is in how they perceive physical objects. Descartes develops a somewhat realist view in his meditations while Berkeley argues that his non-realist perception can sufficiently account for anything a realist would be able to with their system of philosophy. Essentially, Berkeley states that what Descartes believes as corporeal is simply a false understanding of the ideas given to him by God.

To further understand this, we have to understand how each man came to these beliefs. Descartes came to the conclusion that he could not trust his senses due to the fact that they weren’t totally reliable via a chain of reasoning that held nothing as automatically ‘true’. In spite of the fact that his senses were not completely reliable, the fact that they did sense something was proof enough that material existed because that is what his physical senses were limited to.

Now, as Descartes began with the sole fact that he could think, Berkeley b

egan with everything that he perceived is an idea, and the source of these ideas come from a supreme

Sorry, but full essay samples are available only for registered users

Choose a Membership Plan
being or God. He firmly believed in physical objects, but they were only manifestations of the ideas given to him by God, not made of material. Likewise interaction with these ideas are ideas also supplied from God. For example, if Berkeley hit a wall, the pain felt was not caused by the wall but by God who is consistent in expensing the idea of pain with the idea of hitting a wall.

Indirect realism explains there is a ‘knower’, in this case each of the philosophers, and in turn is given an idea of an object. The source of that idea is where the two men disagree. For Descartes, it is the material of the object that produces the idea in which the interpretation of this idea is self-powered. And if this interpretation is self-powered, people may experience different things having distinct perspectives. On the other hand, Berkeley believes the idea is produced by God and is maintained for everyone to experience the same thing.

I believe that both of these men were extremists. Not that they were bookends and the truth lay somewhere in the middle, but rather two points that lay on the surface of a multifaceted object. I’m not saying the truth lies at its center either but each person has to find a place of equilibrium and then push it to induce further thought. As for Descartes and Berkeley, they each picked a direction and ran with till they could go no further. As for the thesis of mediate perception, it is supportable with evidence that pertains to it but is nonsense to those who do not think along those lines. Personally, I don’t know if everyone senses things differently but I am convinced that matter does exist along with a God.

We can write a custom essay on

Descartes Vs Berkeley Perception Essay Sample ...
According to Your Specific Requirements.

Order an essay

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

A Mind Is a Slave of Passion

While he may best be remembered for his classic autobiography Confessions, St. Augustine was also the author of The Problem of Free Choice, which raises many questions and provides answers for a plethora of questions regarding human life and the ability to think. He titles one of the sections of his book "A Mind is the Slave of Passion Through its Own Choice" (MS). In this section, he reveals many interesting thoughts on human nature through dialogue between two characters, Augustine and Evodious. (E. and A. ) St. Augustine looks to discuss reason, knowledge, the concept of mind and control over it, and passion. The conclusion that is reached at the end of MSPOC by E. and A. is, not surprisingly, the point of the title itself. Throughout most of the dialogue A. seeks to show E. the error of his ways and to take him step-by-step to discover the...

Macbeth's State of Mind

Macbeth's state of mind changes drastically throughout the play, this is shown most evidently through the soliloquys. There are references to world order in each of the soliloquys I will be exploring, which reinforces the character of Macbeth and the way in which an audience sees him. In Act I scene VII, Macbeth seems quite stable in his mind, this could be because he is able to find reasons for his thinking, one of them being his vaulting ambition. It states, "I have no spur to prick the sides of my intent, but only vaulting ambition which o'erleaps itself and falls on th'other." This suggests that if it wasn't for his ambition motivating him, Macbeth would not go through with what he is intending to do. He also criticizes ambition, saying that it forces people to rush into things, causing unwanted circumstances. This shows that he doesn't agree with the...

Mental Model/ Mindsets Paper

Change is an everyday occurrence in life. Individuals are not always in agreement with change because of their mental models or mindsets. These terms describe the brain processes to make sense of what is happening in an individual's environment. This poses a challenge for organizations because some creative ideas may be the steppingstones for progress, success, or provide the competitive edge. AAA Transportation in Waukegan, Wisconsin; an interstate trucking company specializing in transporting wholesale produce in climate controlled trailers is facing reluctance in the proposed change in services offered by the new owner. As a human resources (HR) representative the task is to get two of their reluctant employees to join their team. This paper will cover mental model mindsets and the impacts, the four steps to change and their uses, the five forces of influence and affects, and finally, commonly used mental model mindsets that guide decision-making and influence....

Popular Essays

logo

Emma Taylor

online

Hi there!
Would you like to get such a paper?
How about getting a customized one?