We use cookies to give you the best experience possible. By continuing we’ll assume you’re on board with our cookie policy

Effective Writing Essay Sample

essay
The whole doc is available only for registered users OPEN DOC
  • Pages:
  • Word count: 612
  • Category: writings

Get Full Essay

Get access to this section to get all help you need with your essay and educational issues.

Get Access

Effective Writing Essay Sample

Topic: The use of polygraph tests by law enforcement

Research Question: How accurate are polygraphs as tools for lie detection?

Thesis Statement

Polygraphs are unreliable and are not foolproof, therefore they should not be used by law enforcement as means for determining whether or not a person is telling the truth as well as be admitted as evidence in the court of law.

McCarthy, S. (2000, March 2). Passing the polygraph. Salon. Retrieved August 20, 2006, from http://archive.salon.com/health/feature/2000/03/02/ lie_detection/index.html

The article reveals that professional criminals are the ones most adept at deceiving polygraph devices (more commonly known as lie detectors) and how one can easily beat it with a little knowledge and training. Lie detectors are widely used by various parties especially in the United States. While many people believe in its reliability, evidence suggests that its accuracy and validity is dubious. This article supports this conjecture and shows that it is possible to “Beat the Man”.

Through the author’s research, she discovered that there are countless literature on how one can beat the lie detector–plenty of scientific as well as anecdotal examples were used to illustrate this point. In one study, it was revealed that the person’s responses to polygraphs can be “trained”, meaning one can easily pass the test with enough skill and experience. The author cites many instances from the book “A Tremor in the Blood” by David Lyken that reveal various circumvention techniques.

Also according to Lyken, test results often correspond to the person’s state of mind–if one believes he is innocent, that will be the likely result, regardless of whether or not that person committed a crime. This article would be very useful in supplying evidence for arguing my point on how polygraphs can be inaccurate and untrustworthy–using it as evidence on any case can have innocent people convicted and help the guilty ones get away scot-free–therefore it should not be used as a means for determining truth from lie, as well as be admitted as valid evidence in court.

Neil, B. (2005, January 25). Your Number Is Up When Trying to Lie. Evening Chronicle, p A22.

The article reports how polygraph or lie detector tests can be accurate gauges of a person’s honesty and discusses how this tool can be used for monitoring a convicted sex offender’s risk to the public. The author took a lie detector test herself to illustrate that lies could not escape the polygraph. However, this attempt falls short in proving the test’s infallibility, since it does not necessarily mean that all people who “lie” gets caught.

Shay Addison, the polygraph tester whom the author interviewed herself admitted that accuracy is not absolute–the degree of error, according to her, is about 10%. According to the author, the polygraph test helps in uncovering truth about certain aspects of a crime that an offender may be in denial about. It purportedly allows them “know the way offenders are thinking.” However, she does not cite any reliable source or research supporting polygraph use.

Post-interview responses in the polygraph test are discussed, in which many would confess what they have been holding back (although they would usually already be a fair idea of what is being held back by the offender)—this illustrates that other factors (such as pressure) leading to a perpetrator’s self-confession are the ones that help reveal the truth, rather the polygraph test per se. The article is mainly an exploration into the feasibility of the polygraph’s use as a compulsory test before releasing pedophiles, however it’s conjecture that polygraphs are decisive tools for discovering the truth is fallible and inaccurate

We can write a custom essay

According to Your Specific Requirements

Order an essay

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

How To Find The Best Writing Service

Love writing? Get paid for doing what you love. Many websites pay money for writing articles for them. Unfortunately, a lot of services that offered this opportunity in the past have locked their doors and no longer accept articles from freelancers. The good news is that you will never be limited in your choice of service.You can earn money by writing all kinds of academic assignments...

The Salem Witch Trials

The Crucible, by Arthur Miller, was written during the Salem Witch Trials, in 1962 and during these times the reputation of one\'s name carried so much importance and to add to it in the township of Salem public and private moralities were at right about the same level, as a result the people of Salem were focused on maintaining a public standing in society and...

The Case of the Unhealthy Hospital

You have recently been employed as the Director of Informatics for the Metro Hospital in Brisbane. The Metro Hospital is a 363 bed facility on the Northside of Brisbane. The services include general surgical, general medical, oncology, vascular, ear, nose and throat, palliative care, ophthalmology and maternity and children’s services. It has good links with the General Practitioners who fall into the catchment area for...

A World Only Lit by Fire

Your assignment is to read the book and answer a set of review questions. The questions will be impossible to answer without actually reading the book. The questions do not necessarily address the larger themes discussed in the book, but are intended to highlight interesting details, and simply force a closer reading of the book. I recommend that you keep the questions before you as...

Belonging Creative Writing

Looking into the distance; there floated an insignificant, lonely cloud. Separated from its kind. Roosters were cooing early in the morning and her eyes came to life. Just another day. Better get ready she thought. Tired from sleep, Angela threw on her largest coat and searched for the door. There was a tingling sensation once she stepped in the white tiled room. At the polished...

Sorry, but copying text is forbidden on this website. If you need this or any other sample, we can send it to you via email.

We can't stand spam as much as you do No, thanks. I prefer suffering on my own.
logo

Emma Taylor

online

Hi there!
Would you like to get such a paper?
How about getting a customized one?