We use cookies to give you the best experience possible. By continuing we’ll assume you’re on board with our cookie policy

History and Philosophy of Psychology Essay Sample

essay
The whole doc is available only for registered users OPEN DOC

Get Full Essay

Get access to this section to get all help you need with your essay and educational issues.

Get Access

History and Philosophy of Psychology Essay Sample

Abstract

This essay answers the following two part question:  Critically examine the claim that logical positivism and social constructionism are similar in some important respects.   If they are similar, what are the consequences of this for psychology’s future as a scientific discipline? Conclusions are drawn based on research done.

History and Philosophy of Psychology

Critically examine the claim that logical positivism and social constructionism are similar in some important respects.

            Logical positivism definition

            Logical positivism holds that philosophy should aspire to the same sort of rigor as science and that it should provide strict criteria for judging sentences true, false and meaningless (Dictionary.Labourtalk.com 2005)

            Logical positivism made use of symbolic logic, endorsed the verifiability principle as a criterion of meaning and attached great importance to the analysis of language of meaning.  Philosophers in this era (1920 – 1936) included Schlick, Reichenbach and Carnap. Logical positivism was born from positivism, and preceded logical empiricism, post positivism and post modernism.

            Social constructionism definition

            Social constructionism is defined as the view that the phenomena of the social and cultural world and their meanings are created in human social interaction. Taken further, social constructionism can be applied to social research itself . . . . The approach often, though not exclusively, draws on idealist philosophical orientations. (Seale, C.  2004)   The idealist seeks a reassuring, consoling, kindred universe (Stove, 1991)

            Similarities

The received view is that logical positivism and social constructionism are anti-thetical.  However, because they are equivalent in some important regards, this received view is not an accurate one – the following three similarities can be drawn between the two disciplines.   Firstly, logical positivism exponents Schlick and Carnap disconnect what is known and experienced from scientific knowledge.  The essence of extra-mental reality is in their eyes not possible.  Similarly, social constructionism draws a distinction between what is known and what is experienced.

         Secondly, logical positivism lengthens the doctrine of conventionalism from the commonly accepted principles of geometry to logic, mathematics and some theoretical propositions.  Social constructionism, albeit unwittingly, does the same to all propositions of science.

Thirdly, Wittgenstein’s ‘meaning as use’ thesis is drawn upon in both disciplines – in logical positivism, it is used with Schlick’s later defense of the verifiability principle and operationism, and in social constructionism it is invoked to substantiate claims that all meanings of scientific terms are derived from the context of its usage.

If they are similar, what are the consequences of this for psychology’s future as a scientific discipline?

The Concise Oxford Dictionary (Fowler and Fowler, 1976) gives us the following definition of the term “psychology”: It is the science of  the nature, functions and phenomena of the human soul or mind and the treatise on, or the system of this.  Because it is based on a science, psychology is therefore a scientific discipline.  By nature, a scientific discipline develops in stages and is influenced by the beliefs and thoughts of it’s exponents at any given time.  In addition, scientific disciplines are also based on knowledge and on proven facts.

Therefore, if as is suggested by the fact that there are various similarities between  logical positivism and social constructionism, psychology may be moving into a new stage whereby these similarities which include distinctions between what is known and what is experienced, claims, which are being substantiated, that all scientific terms are derived from their usage, and doctrines of conventialism which are being lengthened, have to be considered, the implications for psychology as a scientific discipline are substantial.

It stands to reason that if ideas from past movements have had an impact on the way that psychology is viewed, perceived and judged, ideologies from this new development would have a similar effect on psychology as a whole.

Conclusion

A critical examination has been done on the claim that logical positivism and social constructionism are similar in some respects, and the conclusion of this part of the question is that this claim has been shown to be true.  In support of this, three examples of these similarities have been cited in this essay.  The second part of the question, the consequences of these similarities for psychology’s future as a scientific discipline have been considered.  The conclusion is drawn that these implications will be substantial in that history has proven that psychology has been influenced in the past by the thoughts and research of its exponents..

References

Dictionary.Laborlawtalk.com. (2005)  Retrieved 16 Jun 2005 from the website http://encyclopedia.laborlawtalk.com/Logical positivism

Fowler, H.W, Fowler F.G The Concise Oxford Dictionary (1976) (6th edition) Oxford at the Clarendon Press

Seale, C Researching Society and Culture (2004) Retrieved 16 Jun 2005 from the website http://www.brunel.ac.uk/~hsstcfs/glossary.htm

Stove, D The Plato Cult and Other Philosophical Follies (1991) Oxford Basil Blackwell

We can write a custom essay

According to Your Specific Requirements

Order an essay

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

A Brief Look At The History Of...

Throughout the history of civilization man has often made monuments in many varied forms symbolic of the cultures they live in. These monuments are usually represented through arts of architecture, landscaping, painting, and sculpture. These diverse forms of art have their own unique qualities, all of which can be accented with sculpture in some way. As sculpture usually relates closely to the other arts in...

13th And 14th Century Motets

The motet is hardly a term that can be defined in brief. It is a word that requires a descriptive analysis for each time period. Throughout its history, the motet has taken on several different forms and ideas. A significant difference in the definition of the motet can be seen between the 13th and 14th centuries. It is appropriate to begin in the 13th century,...

A Troubled Paradise

Sovereignty is a sway favor of the omnipotent Almighty Allah to humankind; freedom, by all means, refers to human beings and to other creatures and does hold its magnitude in all aspects. It has widely been manifested by the human history that human beings have ever been striving for freedom, thus, the impression bands no dilemma in it as liberty stands to be the at...

AP United States History

The problem of racism has existed in America historically. From the moment Columbus arrived on the continent, confronting the Native Americans, to the tensions regarding race that exist today, race relations have always played a large role in the transformation of this country. One of the largest demonstrations of racism in this country is the antagonism that has been directed towards African Americans for decades....

Struggles of King Louis IX

The Seventh Crusade Alexis Behnke 11-13-1 War. When we think of it we usually dont think of something that is approved of the people. Its a situation in which people want it to end so that their loved ones can come home. But with these eight wars that occurred in the middle ages, the pope approve them-well not all of them-for the sake of Jerusalem-The...

Get Access To The Full Essay
icon
300+
Materials Daily
icon
100,000+ Subjects
2000+ Topics
icon
Free Plagiarism
Checker
icon
All Materials
are Cataloged Well

Sorry, but copying text is forbidden on this website. If you need this or any other sample, we can send it to you via email.

By clicking "SEND", you agree to our terms of service and privacy policy. We'll occasionally send you account related and promo emails.
Sorry, but only registered users have full access

How about getting this access
immediately?

Become a member

Your Answer Is Very Helpful For Us
Thank You A Lot!

logo

Emma Taylor

online

Hi there!
Would you like to get such a paper?
How about getting a customized one?

Couldn't Find What You Looking For?

Get access to our huge knowledge base which is continuously updated

Next Update Will Be About:
14 : 59 : 59
Become a Member