We use cookies to give you the best experience possible. By continuing we’ll assume you’re on board with our cookie policy

Pay disagreements between Cathay Pacific Airways and Cathay’s pilots and flight attendants Essay Sample

  • Pages: 3
  • Word count: 657
  • Rewriting Possibility: 99% (excellent)
  • Category: airways

Get Full Essay

Get access to this section to get all help you need with your essay and educational issues.

Get Access

Introduction of TOPIC

The issue that I am going to examine is the two pay disagreements between Cathay Pacific Airways and Cathay’s pilots and flight attendants. The Court of Final Appeal ruled that under the employment Ordinance, Cathy must include certain allowances and a commission in addition to the basic salary when calculating its cabin crew’s pay during statutory holidays and annual leave (Chiu, 2012, para. 3). Another judgment is the Court of Final Appeal ordered Cathay to pay HK$850,000 in damages to each of the 18 pilots it sacked over their 2001 industrial action (Chiu, 2012, para. 11).

From the first judgment, it indicated the dynamic human resource management environment. The three flight attendants who filed the lawsuit are from the Cathay Pacific Airways Flight Attendants Union (CPAFAU), which is the trade union of the cabin crew employed by Cathay Pacific Airways Limited. The lawsuit shows that the unions become a third party to deal collectively with their employer. In my opinion, a union is an effective way to deal with the employer. This is because the more the employees joined in the union, the larger the bargaining power to the employer.

From the case, the three flight attendants used about four years to deal with the lawsuit and it started from the claims lodged with the Labour Tribunal. The CPAFAU serve as an important role to contribute in the lawsuit since it pay for the cost of legal consultation. C

athay Pacific Airways also have a staff called Manager of Personnel Strategy & Relations to cope

with the human resource management of the company, such as dealing with the union to maintain employee and labour relations (Apple Daily, 2009).

Besides, legal consideration is also one of the factors in the environment of Human Resources Management. The companies in Hong Kong should follow the local legislation, such as the Employment Ordinances and Minimum Wage Ordinance in Hong Kong. According to the lawsuit between Cathay Pacific Airways and the three flight attendants, the Employment Ordinance ruled that Cathay should include commission on duty-free sales and allowances for line duty and ground duty when calculating its cabin crew’s pay during statutory holidays and annual leave (Chiu, 2012, para. 4). It shows that the legislation will affect the human resources management, for example the compensation.

From my point of view, the legislation can protect the right of the employees. According to the Employment Ordinance Chapter 11 Protection against Anti-union Discrimination, every employee shall have the rights to take part in the activities of the trade union at any appropriate time, if the employee is a member or an officer of a trade union. An employer shall not dismiss, penalise or discriminate against an employee for exercising the above rights. In the lawsuit between Cathay and the 18 pilots, the Court of Final Appeal ordered Cathay to pay HK$850,000 in damages to each of the 18 pilots, including HK$150,000 each for dismissing them on grounds that they took part in work-to-rule union activities. It shows that the Employment Ordinance protect the employees to take part in union activities like industrial action (Chiu, 2012, para. 12).

I suggested that the Cathay Pacific Airways should follow the judgment of the Court of Final Appeal. This is because the lawsuit is known by the Hong Kong people, especially those of the potential employees. It may damage the perception of the potential employees over the company. They may think that Cathay Pacific Airways do not value their employees. Therefore, the potential employees may not consider Cathay as a good employer and it may affect the recruitment of the company. Moreover, the existing staff may lose the morale to work and it may affect the service quality indirectly. To conclude, the environment of human resource management is dynamic and it is affected by many factors like legal consideration and unions.

Sorry, but full essay samples are available only for registered users

Choose a Membership Plan

We can write a custom essay on

Pay disagreements between Cathay Pacific Airways a ...

According to Your Specific Requirements.

Order an essay

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

JetBlue Airways Corporation

JetBlue Airways Corporation, Jetblu for short, is one of the biggest air treval company in the United States. JetBlu is the 6 largerst airline in America. The company is headquartered in the Long Island City neighborhood of the New York City, with its main base at John F. Kennedy International Airport. It also maintains corporate offices in Cottonwood Heights, Utah and Orlando, Florida. During it operation, JetBlu has faced up with many tragedies and problems. Typicaly is thr problematic flight happened in Valentine day February 14, 2007. Most people thought that misfortune even put an end for the airline. Nonetheless, JetBlue not only survive, but it growing, earns profit and become the favorite airline of many people. So we wonder what is the secret behind JetBlu phenomenon. Throughout the company case ‘’ JetBlue: Delighting Customers Through Happy Jetting ‘’ with five discursive questions, we will reveal JetBlu strategy lead to...

Bussiness-British Airways Coursework

A good website should always be easy to navigate and should open easily and quickly. An interesting website should not be aimed at one age group, and should always differ between teenagers and adults so that everyone would browse on it. A good website would be exciting and their products should always be promoted well by advertising special offers etc. A website which would show of good standard should be colourful and eye catching which would make the person want to look at it again and again. Another thing a good website should always acquire is that the information should be easily found using a search bar. Sizes and colours of the fonts all contribute to a successful website. Flash animations should also be used in order to catch the reader's attention. In a well successful website the actual information should be very interesting making sure the reader is not...

British Airways Case Study

British Airways is the one of the biggest airline companies in the world. It is the fifth biggest passenger carrying overall. It is based in London's Heathrow Airport, which is the world leader for international airport. At present, as airline industry leader, it has a longer history and the route networks cover destinations in 133 countries with 373 aircrafts. It has 50,086 employees for the UK airline service. It is one of the biggest employers in the UK. In recent years, British Airways has been making corporate loses. For example, in 2002, it has made a loss of 142 millions and the share price has been decreasing since 2000. For this particular report, we analyse the external and internal environments in which British Airways is operating. We have summarised the SWOT of British Airways. Moreover, the future recommendations have been delivered according to the analysis above. ENVIRONMENT ANALYSIS EXTERNAL ENVIRONMENT...

Popular Essays


Emma Taylor


Hi there!
Would you like to get such a paper?
How about getting a customized one?