We use cookies to give you the best experience possible. By continuing we’ll assume you’re on board with our cookie policy

St Augustine and Ireneus Essay Sample

essay
  • Pages: 3
  • Word count: 777
  • Rewriting Possibility: 99% (excellent)
  • Category: god

Get Full Essay

Get access to this section to get all help you need with your essay and educational issues.

Get Access

Introduction of TOPIC

1. St Augustine’s Theodicy

In the beginning, God created a wholly good creation that was mutable meaning that it had the potential to change. The creation was rich and diverse and there was harmony and balance in it.

However, God gave the angels and mankind freewill, which brought sin and decay into the world. Sin is the absence of good and those who sin will be punished. They will be punished in hell. [Augustine’s theodicy 5th century]

He wrote it in a book called the confessions of St Augustine.

Evaluation

Therefore, God is not responsible for evil the angels and mankind are, since God gave them freewill. A question that could be asked is why, if creation was wholly good, would the angels choose to rebel. This could be responded to that since the creation was rich and diverse there must be grades of morality as well. I.e. greater and lesser goods.

It can be said that Augustine’s clarity on evil merely being a lack of good is successful. Augustine said that evil is a ‘privation’, merely a lack of goodness. Like a bird without a wing or as St Basil said an eye without sight.

Many point out that if God is all loving then why would He plan hell as part of His creation. Scholars respond that since God is all knowing and, knowing that man would rebel he planned for His only son Jesus to give people a second chance. That is why in John 9 sin is said to be a ‘happ

y event’. The theodicy is strong since it follows biblical

Sorry, but full essay samples are available only for registered users

Choose a Membership Plan
teaching. From God’s standpoint [aesthetic theme] the whole of creation is good. Like an analogy of a painting. There might be shadows and light yet the whole painting is good.

There must be punishment for sin in order to restore the harmony and balance.

2. Ireneus – Irenean Theodicy

Ireneus in the second century said that God made the best possible world for its purpose. He said that we are all immature beings and that this world is a vale of soul making.

Evil is presented to us as a stimulus, risk or challenge in order that we all obtain moral and spiritual growth as we are all children of God and as such must achieve an afterlife.

Evaluation

Ireneus writing in the 2nd century traced evil back to human freewill but unlike Augustine, did not deny that God was somehow responsible.

There are various strengths and weaknesses to the theodicy. These include the concept of heaven for all, which seems unjust. What is the point if at the end; we are all going to achieve the goal?

Religious people object the theodicy since it contradicts the Bible and the Qu’ran, which promise punishment for the unrighteous. The Bible promises Hell.

The gravity of suffering is unacceptable. Is there not too much suffering? What about those who cannot cope? Does the extent of suffering such as the Holocaust have to be so great?

D.Z. Philip makes an extremely valid point when he argues that it would never be justifiable to hurt someone in order to help them. Love can never be expressed by the point of suffering.

On the other hand, John Hick makes a strong point when he agrees that goodness that has already been developed by freewill is better than ready made ‘goodness of robots’.

Hick points out that we are created at a distance which he calls an ‘epistemic’ distance with regards to dimension of knowledge from God and he points out that man would be overwhelmed if he knew of God’s expectations of him. We are created in God’s image and must grow to his likeness. Therefore it is seen as a modern theory.

The theodicy is also strong as the evolution theory can be accommodated with it.

However it is viewed as an elitist theory, what about those who cannot cope? It is however, a much more positive theodicy than that of Augustine.

We can write a custom essay on

St Augustine and Ireneus Essay Sample ...
According to Your Specific Requirements.

Order an essay

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

A Philoshpical Approach to the Finding of...

The question of God's existence has been debated through the history of man, with every philosopher from Socrates to Immanuel Kant weighing in on the debate. So great has this topic become that numerous proofs have been invented and utilized to prove or disprove God's existence. Yet no answer still has been reached, leaving me to wonder if any answer at all is possible. So I will try in this paper to see if it is possible to philosophically prove God's existence. Before I start the paper there are a few points that must be established. First is a clear definition of Philosophy of Religion, which is the area of philosophy that applies philosophical methods to study a wide variety of religious issues including the existence of God. The use of the philosophical method makes Philosophy of Religion distinct from theology, which is the study of God and any type...

A Day as a Gay

This essay is the story of my life, in a way. "A clean heart create for me, God; renew in me a steadfast spirit." Psalm 51:12 I was raised in a close, loving household and went to parochial school. When I began to experience attraction to male peers in junior high school, I didn't know what to make of the feelings. Mostly, I stuffed them down, decided this was an adolescent phase, and went along with my life. At 13, I began to masturbate daily, often fueled by fantasies of guys in my class. I told myself this phase would pass; however, when friends in high school started dating girls, bragging of their exploits, I couldn't relate. I knew many girls who were my friends, but I'd never felt the slightest spark of romantic interest in them. Through high school and college, I dated several girls and dutifully "made out" with a...

1st Corinthians

Corinthians is a letter written from the apostle Paul to the Corinthian people. In this letter, Paul logically approaches and addresses many issues. He advises on the quarrels in the Corinthian church. He delves into the issue of morality, telling what is and is not appropriate. Finally, he directly broaches the subject of church matters and faith. Throughout the letter, Paul stresses the unity of the church as well as an all-consuming devotion to God. To begin with, Paul describes how there is a division in the Corinthian church between followers of different leaders. He quickly chastises the people for being so foolish as to squabble. There is but one God and the various leaders are inconsequential because they should all be united in worshipping the one true God. They have faith in God, not men. This makes a great deal of sense and is perfectly logically sound because they...

Popular Essays

logo

Emma Taylor

online

Hi there!
Would you like to get such a paper?
How about getting a customized one?