We use cookies to give you the best experience possible. By continuing we’ll assume you’re on board with our cookie policy

Stanley Cohen and Stuart Hall Essay Sample

essay
  • Pages: 4
  • Word count: 1,049
  • Rewriting Possibility: 99% (excellent)
  • Category: sociology

Get Full Essay

Get access to this section to get all help you need with your essay and educational issues.

Get Access

Introduction of TOPIC

Stanley Cohen (1973) suggests that the media depiction of anti-social behaviour helps to construct folk devils. Folk devils become the focus of public fears and anxieties. They are made to stand for wider problems and concerns and, in the process, become the figures who exemplify ‘what is wrong with society today’. Today’s folk devils might be the ‘yobs’, ‘hoodies’, ‘yobettes’ or ‘alco-yobs’ referred to in newspaper headlines. In Cohen’s original study they were the ‘mods’ and ‘rockers’, members of two youth cultures who sometimes fought each other and attacked seaside shops in mid-1960’s Britain.

These mobile young people (mods were associated with motor scooters and rockers with motorbikes) were portrayed as being out of place and out of control, and thus threatening to both social order and the normal expectations of young people’s behaviour. Their apparent affluence, mobility and potential for violence were seen as profoundly disturbing.

Cohen argues that through the portrayal of such folk devils, the media can create a moral panic in society at large. By making folk devils a focus for wider anxieties, the media increase or amplify those anxieties, shaping a mood of public fear and outrage. This fear and outrage then produces demands that ‘something must be done’ (to restore order and punish the disorderly).

A key point about a moral panic is that it is irrational. The fears that it generates are out of proportion to the scale of the actual behaviour that is the original focus for the panic. In part, this is because the panic focuses many fears and anxieties, but it also reflects the dramatisation of the folk devils as alien or evil. Folk devils are typically pictured as ‘mindless’: their behaviour is so different from that of ‘normal’ people that they can only be dealt with by brutal punishment. Unlike ‘normal’ people, they do not have meaningful or comprehensible reasons for their behaviour. This dramatised distinction between ‘normal people’ and ‘deviants’ is central to Cohen’s analysis of moral panics.

For Cohen, the media play a major role in creating moral panics by fostering irrational fears about anti-social behaviour. The role of the media is the central focus of his work. He suggests that ‘moral entrepreneurs’ (politicians and self-appointed representatives of ‘outraged ordinary people’ or the ‘silent majori

ty’) play a role in building the moral panic by fuelling outrage and demanding action. These moral

Sorry, but full essay samples are available only for registered users

Choose a Membership Plan
entrepreneurs are used by the media to define the situation, frame the problem and add weight to the sense of panic or crisis.

However, beyond suggesting that moral panics reflect – and work on – deep-seated social anxieties, Cohen does not offer many reasons as to why the press or television should create folk devils or start new moral panics. Nevertheless, his ideas of moral panics and folk devils have proved to be significant ones. Many studies since his original work have made use of these concepts, especially in relation to media representations of young people and anti-social or disorderly behaviour. Stuart Hall

Stuart Hall and his co-authors (1978) argue that the growth in media coverage of crime in Britain during the early 1970s contributed to a widespread belief that there was a crisis in society: a crisis that involved an apparent breakdown in law and order. This crisis was focused on a new ‘folk devil’: the mugger (involved in street robbery). ‘Mugging’ was a term imported from the United States: a society viewed in Britain as marred by urban disorder, violent crime and racial conflict.

Hall et al. emphasise the important role played by the media in constructing crime and disorder. They draw on Cohen’s study and his ideas of folk devils and moral panics. However, they locate the media’s role – and the construction of ‘mugging’ as a crisis of law and order – in wider social and political conflicts. By the early 1970s, they argue, a long period of political ‘consensus’ (general agreement about the direction of British society and how it should be governed) was breaking down.

The British economy was experiencing trouble and there was growing industrial unrest with strikes increasing. However, there were many other forms of social and political dissent: conflict between Unionists and Nationalists in Northern Ireland, the rise of feminism, the emergence of black and anti-racist politics, the growth of student politics and the counter-culture, as well as new types of social disturbance associated with young people (a rise in football violence, for example).

According to Hall and his colleagues, the British state (representing the British ruling class) tried to define this multiple economic, social and political crisis as a problem of crime and disorder. That is, they identified it as a crisis of law and order that demanded tougher policing and sentencing. Politicians, senior police officers, judges and other spokespeople acted as ‘primary definers’: defining the problem and demanding a crackdown on crime.

The media took their cue from these definers – especially in the identification of ‘mugging’ (in which the mugger was usually identified as a dangerous young black man) – as the most alarming example of the ‘rising tide of crime’. These constructions of crisis in the media addressed public anxieties and concerns about the state of Britain and turned them into a moral panic about mugging.

In the process, Hall et al. claim two things happened. First, the real and deep-seated causes of the crisis were obscured. Inequality, conflict and dissent were instead turned into a crisis of law and order that needed more and tougher policing (hence their book’s title: Policing the Crisis).

Second, Britain took a step towards becoming a ‘Law and Order society’ in which police powers were extended, sentencing got tougher and politicians could always claim the need to be ‘tough on crime’. Young black men were increasingly likely to be ‘stopped and searched’ by police and be viewed as threatening, dangerous and disorderly. This created a long-lasting tension in many British cities.

We can write a custom essay on

Stanley Cohen and Stuart Hall Essay Sample ...
According to Your Specific Requirements.

Order an essay

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

Sociocultural Influence

Literary works are influenced by the time and environment in which they are set. They exist in a social, political, and historical environment and reflect the value of the culture and history of people. The themes in “This Is What It Means to Say Phoenix, Arizona” authored by Alexie Sherman have a direct relationship with Alexie’s experience. Much of Alexie’s life in America can be seen in the story. He was born in 1966 and raised in Washington’s Wellpinit within and Indian reservation called Spokane. Both of his parents were Indians. His early life was characterized by health problems. He was born with hydrocephalus (Grassian). The chances of him surviving were low. Alexie’s father had even invited a Catholic priest to perform final rites on him. Alexie overcame the problem and survived. However, doctors predicted that he would suffer from retardation. This did not come to be. However, he suffered...

Chitungwiza - Socio-economic Data

The purpose of this report is to help the Chitungwiza Town Council to rehabilitate the sewage system and clear the drains in Rovambira street which have been blocked for over a decade. Throughout floods have been one of the most severe natural catastrophes, which brought about loss of lives and huge economic losses in addition to influence on community activities and adverse effects on the environment. The focus is given to flooding of urban drainage systems. Urban climates, human activities and land use vary quickly and great with time. INTRODUCTION The study explores the impact of floods on the socio-economic livelihoods of people in Chitungwiza. The aim of this study is to provide a thorough understanding of the impact of floods on the socioeconomic livelihoods and underlying causes of the community’s vulnerability. The contribution of the report should compel other stakeholders to undertake further research in issues that may arise...

Social Media Pros and Cons

Over the past few years, many people have come to rely on social media for entertainment, news and advertisements. Nowadays a person can get all sorts of information on the internet whether it be good or bad for the person in general. Occasionally, it can prove disadvantages to many people, at other times it can be a blessing. This leaves a question for consideration; is social media an asset or a hindrance in our lives? One of the main arguments in favor is that it can help connect with anyone from around the world regardless of time zone or location with no effort. It can help connect with friends or family and it can even associate you with strangers, with whom you can learn their cultures and traditions from. Another key point to remember is, it can educate easier by allowing students learn from experts and professionals without revealing your...

Popular Essays

logo

Emma Taylor

online

Hi there!
Would you like to get such a paper?
How about getting a customized one?