We use cookies to give you the best experience possible. By continuing we’ll assume you’re on board with our cookie policy

The Body/Soul Split is a Myth Created by Philosophers Such as Plato Essay Sample

essay
  • Pages: 3
  • Word count: 593
  • Rewriting Possibility: 99% (excellent)
  • Category: plato

Get Full Essay

Get access to this section to get all help you need with your essay and educational issues.

Get Access

Introduction of TOPIC

The belief in life after death or of an immortal soul is not a new occurrence. Philosophers such as Plato, Aristotle and Hick have made attempts at explaining their views on the soul, as well as people like Dawkins, who argue that there is no such thing as the soul at all.

Plato was what is known as a dualist. He believed that the body and the soul were separate things, that the soul animates the body and that the body is mortal, whereas the soul is immortal, and so survives death. Upon the bodies death, Plato believe the soul would be released from it’s “prison” and allowed to look upon the forms. He believed that to see the forms the soul must be released from the body in which it is imprisoned as the body is only a distraction to the soul, merely by requiring food to survive, it also fills us with desires and wants and lusts and loves. All of these are a distract a soul from viewing the forms.

In his works, Plato describes the soul as simple and without parts, meaning that it cannot be split or divided into different sections, however, when referring to the soul in a body, Plat

o goes onto say it is complex. By this he means that there are different aspects to a person’s

soul, but it is still in one part. He used a diamond to illustrate his point, as there are many faces on a diamond, but it cannot be split. The different faces, or aspects of the soul are similar to Freud’s division of the mind. The aspects are Reason, which searches for the truth and rules the soul; Spirit, this includes a number of aspects which can be trained, such as aggressiveness, being honourable and your emotions and Desire or Mercenary. This is linked with the idea of hedonism and seeking pleasures for the self, he split the desires up further into those that are necessary, those that are unnecessary and perverted desires. It is also known as mercenary because fufilling these desires will invariably cost money.

Plato gives two arguments for his soul. The argument from knowledge and the argument from opposties. The argument from knowledge suggests that learning is simply a matter of remembering what the soul has previously known from the world of the forms. He uses the example of “equals” here, pointing out that we can see things in equals around us, like two stones of equal size but we have never seen the form of equals, however this does not stop us from applying the concept of equals to different things.

The argument from opposites is that we can see everything in the physical world consists of opposites and that the opposite of living was death. For death to be a “thing” he said there must exist a soul to make something “alive”

Plato’s views on the soul are very much dependant on his theory of the forms and so the same weaknesses apply to both. Arguments such as how can one “see” the forms when seeing is a process linked with a body, how can a disembodied soul “see” anything? Some people see learning as acquiring new knowledge and so not an act of remembering. The argument of opposites can be disputed as the idea that everything has an opposite can be challenged.

Sorry, but full essay samples are available only for registered users

Choose a Membership Plan

We can write a custom essay on

The Body/Soul Split is a Myth Created by Philosoph ...

According to Your Specific Requirements.

Order an essay

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

A Life Sketch of Plato and His...

If Thales was the first of all the great Greek philosophers, Plato must remain the best known of all the Greeks. The original name of this Athenian aristocrat was Aristiclis, but in his school days he received the nickname "Platon" (meaning "broad") because of his broad shoulders. Plato was born in Athens, Greece to one of the oldest and most distinguished families in the city. He lived with his mother, Perictione, and his father, Ariston (Until Ariston died. ) Born in an aristocratic and rich family, Plato's childhood was indulged within luxury. But his life changed when he came across Socrates. Socrates, a Greek philosopher who lived from 470-399 BC. He devoted all his time with young citizens discussing philosophy and questioning their confidence in the truth of popular opinions. As a young man, Plato grew up wanting to be a politician. However, after Socrates' execution in 399 BC had...

A Review of Plato’s Meno

Plato presents in his dialogue, titled Meno, the distinction between genuine knowledge and true opinion. In the text, he refers to knowledge as the form and definition of something that is changeless, where as true opinion can be altered and is not restricted in the way knowledge is by having standards of a form. Plato includes the characters of Socrates and Meno, a pupil of Gorgias, to discuss the nature of virtue and knowledge. The dialogue is provoked by Meno posing the question: How will you look for [virtue], Socrates, when you do not know at all what it is? How will you aim to search for something you do not know at all? If you should meet with it, how ill you know that this is the thing that you did not know?  (Meno 80d). Socrates begins his discussion with Meno by comparing himself to a torpedo fish, which...

Plato and Aristotle: An Introduction to Greek...

Since Socrates, what is the political significance of "reason" for the meaning of virtue for Plato and Aristotle? In other words, what role does reason and virtue play in politics, citizenship, and the formation of a good or just society? And, how does Aristotle's view differ from Plato's? In an effective political system, reason and virtue are very important. For the formation of a good society, one must incorporate justice and equality into it and this cannot be done without reason and virtue. The people of a certain society or political system must have the quality of honesty in them and they should also have a sound reasoning for a better understanding and analysis of what is happening around them. Plato and Aristotle are the most eminent Greek philosophers who have studied and worked on ethics, politics, science etc. Plato, being the student of Socrates and Aristotle, being the student...

Popular Essays

logo

Emma Taylor

online

Hi there!
Would you like to get such a paper?
How about getting a customized one?