We use cookies to give you the best experience possible. By continuing we’ll assume you’re on board with our cookie policy

The Function of Humor in Woody Allen’s Films Essay Sample

essay
  • Pages: 5
  • Word count: 1,289
  • Rewriting Possibility: 99% (excellent)
  • Category: dementia film films

Get Full Essay

Get access to this section to get all help you need with your essay and educational issues.

Get Access

Introduction of TOPIC

The function of humor in Woody Allen’s films is argued by many critics. This essay will focus on the comments of Ray Carney, Sam Girgus and Nancy Pogel. Carney argues that, “Comedy is the wound through which serious meaning bleeds out of Allen’s work.” (Carney, 14). He argues that there is no genuine drama that develops in Allen’s films because of the his execution and his humor. On the other hand, Girgus and Pogel give a more positive position on Allen’s use of humor in his films. This paper will evaluate Carney’s critique on Allen’s humor and an analysis alongside the arguments presented by Girgus and Pogel.

Carney believes that Woody Allen uses humor to avoid having to express the character’s genuine intention and motivation. Allen doesn’t engage his characters in a process of discovery, either social or verbal, that dramatize real life and significant art. He believes that Allen’s characters are really abstract pseudo-characters and that Allen turns to comedic diversions to allow his characters to escape dramatic scenes and situations without engaging in the processes of real life.

Take the scenes in “Annie Hall” for example. Alvy (Woody Allen) and Annie (Diane Keaton) discuss art. The subtitles are completely different from what was being said by both characters. Alvy’s main intention was to ask Annie out. There is also the scene where they are making love and Annie is not completely there in the moment, so the “ghost of Annie” is presented to the audience sitting on a chair.

Carney further argues that Woody Allen presents a cinematic world without authenticity, a reality that has been hygienically cleansed, “…one that extends beyond the cleanliness of the sets to the squeaky-cleanness of the events, plots, and characters.”  This is accomplished, Carney says, through the film’s narration, titles, and music among other devices that seemingly give the film artistic gloss and audience appeal but in reality obscure the real dramatic contents with packaging.

A scene from “Annie Hall” that best explain the previous paragraph is Alvy’s joke at the dinner table. “I’m making excellent progress. Pretty soon when I lie down on his couch, I won’t have to wear the lobster bib.” He’s joking about his lack of progress or growth. A child wears a lobster bib at a restaurant. It’s like saying “pretty soon I’ll be able to take off the training wheels” or “pretty soon I won’t have to wear diapers.”

Carney finds Allen’s cinematic process and use of comedy as fatal flaws. “Every time a scene starts to get truly interesting or complex,” Carney writes, “Allen is just too good at turning it into a joke to allow himself or his viewers to explore it, to learn anything from it. Comedy

is not used to complicate our responses or to enlarge our perspective on an event, but to soften our

Sorry, but full essay samples are available only for registered users

Choose a Membership Plan
view of it, to protect Allen’s characters (and scenes) from becoming truly disturbing.”

He offers an example in “Annie Hall” when Alvy and Annie are offered cocaine. Alvy sneezes and blows the cocaine all over the floor. Carney’s observation is that just when the scene is about to enter the realm of real and significant drama, the scene turns away and is exploited for comedy. (Carney, 7).

In Allen’s defense, Sam Girgus views him as a modern day Charlie Chaplin, and regards his films quite differently than Carney. Starting with the opening monologue in which Alvy reveals his inner thoughts to the audience, the film convinces the viewer into a position that supports the centrality of Alvy as the developing subject within the film’s narrative. Alvy often breaks through the fourth wall and talks to the audience right in front of the camera. Carney sees this as avoidance in “Annie Hall.” On the other hand, Girgus believes it offers a re-interpretative narrative to instill the film with Allen’s artistic vision of human behavior. (Girgus, 44).

He is more interested in the methodology of Woody Allen’s technique – specifically how his narrative approach reorganizes the internal logic of the film’s thematic meaning. Girgus also points out Allen’s constant references to Freud. This is seen in “Hannah and Her Sisters.”  Three sisters, Lee, Holly and Hannah get together and exchange partners. Hannah’s husband Elliot falls in love with Lee. Holly survives a personal crisis and meets Mickey, who happens to be the former husband of Hannah. These affairs occur in two Thanksgivings.

Carney describes the drama in the celebration of Hannah’s family as dramatic avoidance. Hannah is the backbone. Lee is the subject of everyone’s lust. Holly is the odd one out. The inter-action of the sisters among one another and their relationships with their husbands reveals what Girgus’ “brilliant techniques and motifs.”

This is because “Hannah and Her Sisters” is Allen’s most accessible film. He interweaves multiply story lines and presents these in a wonderful and rich, hilarious and human manner. Even during the scene with great dramatic tension, the true element of comedy manages to surface. Examples are the bumbling of Elliot, Holly’s hostility and Mickey’s quest for existence. These are all set along the confines of solemnity.

For Nancy Pogel, on the other hand, Allen represents the Little Man, or “dementia-praecox,” in the tradition of Charlie Chaplin, Harold Lloyd, Buster Keaton, and Bob Hope, who she describes as Allen’s comedy ancestors. (Pogel, 2). His works have somber and philosophical undertones that are reminiscent to the silent films of Chaplin and Keaton.

Allen is also able to combine the comic and tragic elements in “Hannah and Her Sisters.” Pogel views Allen’s humor as dialogic – of resonating in a larger context. His films carry on the dialogues through various ideas, styles and form. (Pogel, 6). Carney concentrates on what he perceives as Allen’s dramatic avoidance, Girgus sees comedic statement while Pogel observe that Allen’s films celebrate the inter-action of the characters and their struggle in the social context.

Carney remarks on Allen’s escape when the scenes get serious (mentioned in the previous paragraph – the subtitles during dinner and Annie’s ghost). Girgus observes the purpose of Allen’s breaking through the fourth wall in order to reach to the audience better in “Annie Hall.” Pogel analyzes the relationship among the characters, specifically the relationship of the sisters and their husbands in “Hannah and Her Sisters.”

Carney concludes that Allen focuses too much on the comedy, thus his shortcoming as a dramatist. This is why his article provides a somehow negative review on the three-time Academy Award winning writer. However, there are critics like Girgus and Pogel who presents Allen’s depth in storytelling through the technique he utilizes in his film and the build up of the characters in his story.

In conclusion, in the above essay I successfully evaluated Carney’s position of how Allen uses humor in his films and analyzed how his position relates to the views of Girgus and Pogel. What Carney, Girgus, and Pogel all share is the desire to understand the films of Woody Allen. What each finds is significantly different, often polarized, and entirely determined by the elements each focuses upon and mostly highly values.

We can write a custom essay on

The Function of Humor in Woody Allen’s Films Ess ...
According to Your Specific Requirements.

Order an essay

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

Record keeping at Greyfriers Nursing Home

What is Data Protection Act? Data Protection Act applies to all health, social care and early years settings. It is a United Kingdom Act of Parliament which explains UK law on the handling of data on perceptible living people. This legislation covers how to deal with private information although the Act itself does not discuss secrecy. This kind of information can only be accessed by care workers who have legal right to look at it and those individuals whose information is being held. Personal data must be kept accurate, up to date and shall not be kept for longer than is necessary as it should only be used for that particular purpose. Data Protection Act is applied to business information, credit card details, health records and social service records. Information should be kept private as it’s only for professional care workers use, data controllers should make sure they password protect...

Non-Profit Capitalism

1. Executive Summary This report defines, examines and promotes a non-profit capitalistic business model. The model endorses enterprises which compete in the free market, but eschews profits in favor of social benefits. This entails an increased workforce with benefits and wages on par with current standards. This increased employee pool works under a staggered shift structure so that each employee only works a 3-day (24 hour) workweek. Labor is scheduled in such a way that there is necessary labor coverage for the firm to function and compete over a traditional 5-day business week. Special attention is given to the prospects of utilizing such a system as a method to increase industry and innovation in the Northeast Ohio region. Northeast Ohio is the default regional example for applicable sections of the report. Financial evidence is provided to show where the opportunities for this system currently exist. The system is analyzed to...

Provide Support for Sleep

1.1 How does sleep contributes to an individual’s wellbeing? Sleep is important for our health and well-being. Extensive research has been done on the effects of sleep. These studies consistently show that sleep plays a vital role in promoting physical health, longevity, and emotional well-being. This explains why, after a good night's sleep, we feel better, our thoughts are clearer, and our emotions are less fragile. Without adequate sleep our judgment, mood, and ability to learn and retain information are weakened. Sleep contributes to an individual's well being by our body producing extra protein molecules while we're sleeping that helps strengthen our ability to fight infection and stay healthy. It helps to reduce the levels of stress and inflammation in your body. Sleep can help lower blood pressure and elevated levels of stress hormones, which are a natural result of today's fast paced lifestyle. It allows the brain to better...

Popular Essays

logo

Emma Taylor

online

Hi there!
Would you like to get such a paper?
How about getting a customized one?