We use cookies to give you the best experience possible. By continuing we’ll assume you’re on board with our cookie policy

“The General” by Siegfried Sassoon Essay Sample

essay
  • Pages: 3
  • Word count: 750
  • Rewriting Possibility: 99% (excellent)
  • Category: poem

Get Full Essay

Get access to this section to get all help you need with your essay and educational issues.

Get Access

Introduction of TOPIC

Q.3 Source C is a poem called “The General” and is written by Siegfried Sassoon, an infantry officer on the Western Front in 1917. He criticises the war effort and the plan of attack the Generals used (going over the top). He comments on two particular soldiers (Harry and Jack) who were killed as a result of the Generals ordering them to go over the top: “But he did for them both by his plan of attack.” So it could be said that Sassoon is blaming the General for Harry and Jack’s death. Of course there were many like Harry and Jack who got wounded or killed when they went over the top.

Siegfried Sassoon enlisted as soon as the war had been declared. However, after spending a long period at the Front, he got wounded and was sent home. But he became convinced that the war was evil and could not be supported. So Siegfried was enthusiastic at the beginning of the war but as time passed by, the reality of the war kicked into him. This was the case for most of the soldiers at the Front, because they would’ve been used to the plan of attack (going over the top) and deaths like Harry and Jack’s. So even though many soldiers weren’t as enthusiastic about the war when they joined, there were bound to be some soldiers who remained patriotic, or were willing to fight through thick and thin.

A well-known proverb that spread within the trenches was: “Lions led by Donkeys”. The lions being the brave soldiers and the donkeys being the Generals

who most of them thought didn’t know how to fight this kind of war.

Sorry, but full essay samples are available only for registered users

Choose a Membership Plan
justify;">So Source C is Sassoon’s personal view (opinion), which is likely to be biased. Because he became anti war after spending a couple of years at the Front. So even though it is an opinion, it can be said that a lot of the soldiers felt the same way. That agrees with my own knowledge. A more cynical approach to war would’ve been appearing in soldiers’ minds as time went by.

Q.4 Source D was written by Lloyd George in 1935 and it’s called “Lloyd George’s War Memoirs”. It is written for the public. He criticises Sir Douglas Haig’s abilities as Commander-in-Chief of the army. He calls him a “…second rate commander…” But he did not attack or sack Haig during the war because he thought it would “undermine public confidence”.

Whereas Source E is written by a historian in 1991 and he’s saying that if the test of a successful General is whether or not he wins wars, then Haig must be judged a success. He says that the war of attrition was the proper way to achieve victory. But the historian accepts that some people criticise the cost of Haig’s methods, but he doesn’t see them coming up with any other methods other than attrition. Source E obviously supports Haig and Source D criticises him.

Well Haig was known as Butcher of the Somme when a lot of British lives were lost there. But this was the reality of a war of attrition. Many attitudes of Germans are that the Somme was the turning point of their war. Because Haig kept pounding and pounding at the enemy. It could be said that he wore them down.

Lloyd George is criticising Haig because people blamed Haig for the immense loss of life at the Somme. And Lloyd George didn’t replace Haig. So now in his memoirs maybe he is self-justifying what he did, because he claims it would’ve dented public confidence but it could’ve in fact boosted public confidence

Source E gives some of the good qualities of Haig. The author (a historian) says that there wasn’t any other way suggested or likely to work except a war of attrition. But the historian also recognises the cost at which Haig won the war.

Both sources are secondary. And there was no censorship issued by the government the time they were written. It is fact that Haig won the war, but at a high price. And the success of a general depends on whether or not he wins wars, does it not?

We can write a custom essay on

“The General” by Siegfried Sassoon Ess ...
According to Your Specific Requirements.

Order an essay

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

One Perfect Rose Poem

In her poem "One Perfect Rose" Dorthy Parker questions the actions of a man from her past and misleads the reader into believing this poem is a romantic tribute to a tender moment. Although this verse comes to us in a lighthearted, comedic style, the reader eventually wonders if Ms. Parker feels blessed or forsaken. Ms. Parker misleads the reader in the first and second stanzas into believing the romantic with word choices like "tenderly", "pure", and "perfect" to describe the rose and its sender directly influencing the readers initial reaction to the poem; as well as he way she writes the poem. Written ABAB format with four lines to each stanza and every other line rhyming, they are short, sweet, and melodic. The musical quality helps draw the reader into believing the poems purpose is a romantic recollection. The tense of the entire poem changes dramatically when reading the...

"Mirror" by Sylvia Plath

When I first read this poem it did nothing for me, but as the days passed I decided to give it another chance and when I re-read it I began to cry, literally cry. I felt like it was speaking to me and saying everything I wouldn't dare say. I guess there is always a poem like that for everyone, one that touches the heart. Sylvia Plath an American, beautiful, talented poet created such masterpieces in her time. Unfortunately Sylvia Plath committed suicide on February 11, 1963. The reason for her tragic death remains a mystery, but there are speculations that it was the outcome of her divorce and loneliness. Though she no longer lives, her poems live on and once in a while touch the hearts of those in need of a voice. The "Mirror" by Sylvia Plath is a deep poem that comes of soft, but when reading...

Era of Good Feelings

During the Era of Good Feelings, the country utilized the driving force of nationalism to unify itself through its time of prospering and developing as a nation. However, territorial and state rights were extremely imperative for the country\'s political agenda. The question of sectionalisms effect has not as often been discussed even though sectionalism was an influential factor in both economics and politics. Both sectionalism and nationalism are not mutually exclusive beliefs but have developed along with each other throughout history. Although they have both affected the United States in different ways during this era, they were both in equally important ways. Nationalism played a large role in the era, due to the fact that it defined it for the most part. This nationalistic attitude influenced the arts as well as the political and economic ideals brought about by this air of unity within the nation. The results of The...

Popular Essays

logo

Emma Taylor

online

Hi there!
Would you like to get such a paper?
How about getting a customized one?