We use cookies to give you the best experience possible. By continuing we’ll assume you’re on board with our cookie policy

To What Extent Was a Lack Popular Support an Obstacle to Unification in 1830-49? Essay Sample

essay
  • Pages: 3
  • Word count: 702
  • Rewriting Possibility: 99% (excellent)
  • Category: politics

Get Full Essay

Get access to this section to get all help you need with your essay and educational issues.

Get Access

Introduction of TOPIC

Italy from 1830-49 saw several political developments pertinent to the Unification of Italy, of which popular support was a key factor. It was not necessarily a decisive one however, as support felt for something does not necessarily translate into political ends. Where the support is for causes that have not been defined as well or the means and ends conceived as fully by a group of people, as was the case at the time, the results tend to be sporadic, partial and contradictory, as was the case with the developments of 1830-49.

The revolutions of the 1820s and ‘30s saw the exclusion of the majorities in the populations of the new governments. Predictably, that majority celebrated and welcomed the fall of those governments, since they stood gain economically from eventual Austrian invasion. There was though, less concerted action from the poor, leading to a result largely determined by the Austrian army. Taking the example of the Naples Lazzaroni, who joined Garibaldi’s expedition in 1861 contributed to the conquest of Naples by incorporating the organisation and tactics of the guerrilla army.

The effect of leadership factored into this period, notably, 2 instances in which Mazzini could have led to the fall of the Roman Republic; when his spending policies created runaway inflation and when his preference for diplomacy actually led to its end by French conquest. Perhaps of greater importance was the leadership structures that existed, the revolutionaries were unable to replicate the levee en masse of the French revolution, whose success came irrespective of the unwillingness of vast

swathes of its population to fight. Examining popular support of

Sorry, but full essay samples are available only for registered users

Choose a Membership Plan
course raises the question of popular support for what? Though this period (’48-’49 especially) is woven into the Risorgimento narrative, many of the territories seemed not to fight for Italy as a state, but their own territory as a state in itself. Both the Sicilian revolutions of 1820 and ’48 were separatist, as well as being crushed by whichever government happened to be in Naples. Despite being adjacent to each other, the government of Bologna neglected to aid Modena during the Austrian invasion of 1831. Piedmont-Sardinia, whose army was a personal one, during the spring of nations, whose leader declined assistance from other groups, exemplified how there could be an Italian state could be achieved by spreading the borders of one of the local states.

It would be inaccurate to ascribe the Risorgimento to be a popular one, that is one supported by the majority in Italy, because while it was true that most had a vision of Italy as a whole, theirs was not the same as any of the many other political groups in Italy at the time. The sharp increase in anticlericalism exhibited by nationalist groups after the Papal Allocution of 1848, suggests that the Italian population was divided by religion and political allegiance to the Catholic Church, whereas before there was a movement to create an Italian federation with the Papacy at its centre. A tangible result of the influence of Catholicism was the pressure on Napoleon III, by his Catholic political supporters, to end the Roman Republic during the spring of nations.

There were objectives common to nearly of all of the revolutionaries in this period, one of which was to resist foreign power, especially Austrian hegemony in the Italian states. The barrier to unification provided by stronger powers abroad was very great. Nearly every major uprising from 1830-49 was ended by foreign military intervention, especially Austrian. The weakness of even the strongest Italian state; Piedmont-Sardinia, relative to foreign powers was made apparent by its acceptance of the end of the 2nd war of Italian independence in 1859 as soon as its leadership discovered that France and Austria had decided on a peace.

So, the Risorgimento was a result of as well as hindered by the pressures exerted by power structures in Europe, the congress powers in particular, the same can be said of popular support if their tacit support by non-action can be counted as support for any result.

We can write a custom essay on

To What Extent Was a Lack Popular Support an Obsta ...
According to Your Specific Requirements.

Order an essay

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

Political Science and World Politics

INTRODUCTION Human rights known since the existence of ancient civilizations. However, the tragic events of the Second World War of 1939-1945, has led to the apparent disappointing conclusion that human rights are not always respected everywhere. That is why on 10 December 1948 by representatives of 50 states members of the United Nations teamed up under the leadership of E. Roosevelt, to determine all the rights that should have every person on the planet and secure them in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. At present, people still are struggling to ensure the rights and their protection, moreover, they openly advocate the extension of rights in various fields. MEANING Nowadays the use of the concept of \"human rights\" has become quite widely used both in everyday life and in political processes, the more space it occupies and in academic research. However, in science and particularly in political and legal sciences,...

Would you have been a Federalist or...

Choosing federalism or Anti-federalism is difficult because both governments work for the establishment of a good nation. But according to me, I believe that any country or nation comprises of many legal boundaries which are made for the betterment of the country. American politics is the one where not only America rules but other countries also follow its footsteps. So government should be powerful and people should abide the rules and regulation of country. In this situation, federalism and Anti-federalism plays an important role in the development of a nation. Federalism is basically a written constitution that is built for the government bodies to participate for the betterment of their country. Rules and regulations pass to local citizens so that they could follow those rules and establish a better society. Any nation could only be successful if its managed and governed by a good government, who works for the citizens,...

To What Extent Was General Custer Responsible...

My first initial judgement of Custer is that he was very arrogant, ignorant and independent. That he only thinks of himself and his own glory and no one else’s (selfish). He will not listen to anyone but and him self and is willing to put other people before himself even and is not a good leader. I think that he is almost fanatic about the war and unlike other solders, gets excited by it. Custer's training and early career Custer's image in the US army was that of glamour, dashing, bravery and ambitious. Custer received many demerits and had a bad reputation for being quite sloppy and unconcerned. But he managed to impress General Sheridan due to his recklessness and sheer courage. After the war ended, he was reverted to captain rank, but made him self popular and a daring Indian fighter. He had been court-marshalled in 1867 which suspended...

Popular Essays

logo

Emma Taylor

online

Hi there!
Would you like to get such a paper?
How about getting a customized one?