We use cookies to give you the best experience possible. By continuing we’ll assume you’re on board with our cookie policy

To What Extent Was Lenin a Good Leader? Essay Sample

essay
  • Pages: 4
  • Word count: 827
  • Rewriting Possibility: 99% (excellent)
  • Category: lenin

Get Full Essay

Get access to this section to get all help you need with your essay and educational issues.

Get Access

Introduction of TOPIC

During the period lasting from 1917 up until 1924, Lenin remained leader of Russia through the Bolshevik party. During this time he made many decisions that could either be described as being reflective of a good or bad leader. This essay will look at to what extent Lenin was a good leader and whether his actions reflected this. In many ways, the actions of Lenin could suggest that he was a bad leader although in a purely Marxist sense. This is because in 1917 when he had achieved power, he made many promises to the people about “what is to be done” and these policies reflected the thinking of a Marxist leader. The policy of ‘War communism’ adopted during the civil war certainly reflected a Marxist leader in which he put severe pressure upon the peasants in the name of the common good of the proletariat. This policy however, was promptly dropped at the end of the war in favour of a more capitalist approach.

This was the adoption of the ‘New Economic Policy’, which was essentially capitalist and went against Marxist views. Therefore this is evidence to suggest that he was not a good Marxist leader although his actions may have reflected those of a good leader. I believe the latter to be the case. Yes, one may argue that his switching of views and failure to remain true to a fixed set of principles was a case of bad leadership, but I think it highlights Lenin’s ability to adapt to the new situations that Russia was facing. In a sense, he was a political chameleon, adapting his views to suit the situation. In context with the times, I believe this to be an example of good leadership as he was doing all in is power to ‘drag’ Russia out of a pitiful state and into the modern world

that other nations had found. If he is guilty of this, then what

Sorry, but full essay samples are available only for registered users

Choose a Membership Plan
a leader he was. Further example of his fantastic leadership comes from the fact he was such a political chameleon. His actions sparked intense opposition from many, even people from his own party. Yet, in style that is only truly reflected by a great leader, he continued to grip on to power. Although some suggest he came to power only by default, due to the fact his political opponents all failed the people in some way, one cannot refute the fact that he had a strong part to play in the people’s eventual dislike of his political enemies in 1917. This was through the careful use of propaganda slogans such as “peace, land, bread”. These modifications to his views enabled him to gain popularity.

However, once they were in charge, they were still not the most favoured party. Only a good leader would be able to remedy this. After all of the revolution of October, they still managed only to win one quarter of the vote in the elections to the Constituent Assembly. Consequently, the Assembly and all hope for a parliamentary republic were removed, in return for a ‘purer’ form of democracy through the Soviets. Under the new Soviet constitution, all other political parties, no matter how allied they were to the Bolsheviks, were banned, and censorship, the secret police, and the death sentence were all reintroduced. In just seven years, 200,000 people were executed, as well as 50,000 people being set to the Gulags, compared to 17,000 people over 50 years under Tsarist rule. It was clear that Lenin sought to drive Russians into Communism ‘with guns’, and once commented “You can’t make an omelette without breaking eggs.”

Although brutal in his methods of retaining power, notably from his secret police force the cheka, he still hung on to power. Lenin was also a fantastic tactician in national affairs. The Brest-Litovsk treaty with Germany sealed their safety in World War 1 despite losing much land. However, he made the treaty on a gamble that Germany would lose the war and Russia would get it’s land back. It paid off. One may suggest that this risky gamble was not wise and therefore makes Lenin a bad leader. Yet, the simple fact remains that it did work and Russia could only reap the rewards. Through all the flaws that Lenin possessed, most notably arrogance, he did make Russia a better place economically, even though it was difficult getting there. On this alone he must be rated a great leader. Had he not have been so great and adapted his views and methods so much, he may not have been successful. He used the time-proven method of trial and error. He succeeded where all others had failed. He may not have been a good Marxist leader, but this was not the question at hand. To what extent was Lenin a good leader? He was a prime example of one.

We can write a custom essay on

To What Extent Was Lenin a Good Leader? Essay Samp ...
According to Your Specific Requirements.

Order an essay

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

How Important Was Lenin to the Success...

The revolution in October of 1917 was the result of many factors, both long and short term. However, the role of Lenin was crucial. Many would say that without his leadership of the revolutionaries and actions in 1917, there never would have been a revolution, but just how true is this? How important was Lenin? In 1887, when Lenin was only seventeen years old, his elder brother was hanged for plotting to assassinate Tsar Alexander III. Throughout the rest of his life, especially whilst studying at Kazan' University, Lenin was seen as the brother of a terrorist and was watched very closely by the police until he was quickly expelled for being a troublemaker and taking part in demonstrations against the university rules. Lenin hated those who had cut short his promising career and had rejected his whole family, the tsarist establishment and the 'bourgeoisie' (a Marxist term referring to...

Lenin and the Bolshevik Revolution

Could the Bolshevik Revolution have taken place without the participation of the founder and perpetual leader of the Bolsheviks? Really, the question seems too silly to ask. Lenin's fingerprints are all over the October insurrection. However, it is not logically inconceivable that a popular uprising could have taken place against the Provisional Government without the aid of Lenin or his party. It will be contended in this chapter that such an uprising was, if not inevitable, then certainly very probable. This will be shown through the use of the model developed in chapter one. The analysis presented in this chapter will proceed through two steps, corresponding to the two questions raised by the model. First it will be shown that there was a strong popular demand for many of the policies which the Bolsheviks were to incorporate into their programme. Some of the groups making these demands (especially the soldiers...

Lenin's Impact On Russia And The Russian...

Lenin had a great impact on Russia and the Russian people with his variety of policies and events that took place during his reign. Any events or policies had both short and long term effects for everyone. I will be looking at both of these. Firstly, there was the Revolution and the new system of government. In 1917, Tsar Nicholas was abdicated from the throne. This was the end of a 300-year-old Romanov dynasty. This happened due to a Bolshevik Revolution led by Lenin. The event happened at that particular time mainly due to Lenin who urged Revolution immediately. He said, "We must not wait! We may lose everything...having obtained the majority in the Soviet...the Bolsheviks can and must take power into their own hands." Lenin wanted the Revolution to go further and to become a dictatorship of the proletariat. He then produced the April Theses, which made a variety...

Popular Essays

logo

Emma Taylor

online

Hi there!
Would you like to get such a paper?
How about getting a customized one?